The phylogenetic relationships among Palaearctic species of the ant genus Tetramorium and its social parasites of the genera Strongylognathtus, Anergates and Teletomyrmex, were investigated electrophoretically at 21 presumptive enzyme loci. The data set comprising 33 species was analysed with distance (UPGMA, Neighbor-joining and least squares statistics) and parsimony methods (independent allele, minimum turnover and mutation coding) in order to rule out analysis-dependent effects. Several groupings were consistently resolved by all procedures. Observed branching patterns support the placement of the three parasite genera and their hosts into the Palaearctic species group of Tetramorium (tribe Tetramoriini). The genus Strongylognathus forms a monophyletic group in which the slave-makers of the S. huberi group constitute the sister group of the inquilines S. testaceus and S. karawajewi (S. testaceus group). Most species of the S. huberi group show very low genetic differentiation. However, little consensus has been found with regard to which Tetramorium species are the closest relatives of Strongylognathus.
According to the electrophoretic data, social parasitism in Palaearctic tetramoriine ants has evolved independently at least twice. Though inquilinism once arose from slave-making ancestors in Strongylognathus, the extreme inquilines Anergates atratulus and Teleutomyrmex schneideri are clearly set apart from the Strongylognathus clade in phylogenetic analyses. Thus, extreme inquilinism cannot be regarded as the endpoint of a single parasitic lineage in the Tetramoriini. In these highly advanced inquilines, evolutionary rates at allozyme loci appear to be higher than those of their Tetramorium hosts. The results do not unambiguously reveal whether Anergates and Teleutomyrmex arose jointly or independently from Tetramorium ancestors. However, a combined analysis using all available evidence supports the former hypothesis. The finding that the Tetramorium parasites are not the closest relatives of their respective host species is discussed in relation to current theories for the evolution of social parasitism.