Predators activate a search image process for the most frequent prey type as a result of repeated chance encounters with that prey. In addition, selective attention to a limited subset of prey visual features should increase the precision with which the prey is discriminated from the background. In our experiment, we investigated the effects of multiple backgrounds on prey detection by captive American kestrels (Falco sparverius). We predicted that the background itself can serve to cue attention towards the prey type and that a most recent experience provided predictive information. As expected, we observed the effects of search image formation where the background was informative (familiar substrate). Nevertheless, search image effects disappeared with extended practice and kestrels rapidly increased the use of unfamiliar background where prey were completely non-cryptic. Our data suggest that short-term changes in prey detection of a predator cue with the background upon which this prey is found. We discussed the results in the light of related studies on neophobia, visual acuity and achromatic and chromatic contrasts.